Sustaining Improvement: Is It a Pipe Dream?

By: Mark Eaton
Submitted: 2007-01-17 15:36:27
Print this article | Tell a friend | For publisher | Social Bookmarking
Rating:
 

There are two questions that seem to be most commonly asked by organisations who are looking to change the direction of their business; namely:

1. Where do I start?

and

2. Why is it so hard?

Research quoted by Henley Management College stated that the UK wastes around ?25Bn per year on improvement programmes which go wrong and our own research, collated from a number of sources, suggests that upwards of 80% of all improvement activities will fail.

With ‘Lean’ becoming the improvement tool of choice within a wide range of sectors, including Financial Services, Armed Forces, NHS, Public Services and the Service Sector, it is already becoming apparent that these sectors are suffering from the same problems with implementation that were first seen in ‘Lean’s’ home, manufacturing.

Whilst organisations have focused on the tools of Lean, everything from adapting 5S and SMED for office and service environments, there has been little thought applied to the methodology of implementation – namely, ‘Where do I start?’

Further analysis shows that many of the reasons why Lean Improvement Programmes fail can be traced back to decisions and actions either taken or omitted prior to the start of the change process – broadly these decisions can be classed as:

* Issues surrounding the planning and application of the tools
* Issues around the engagement of people and the communication of change
* Issues around the development of managers to drive the change
* Issues around the leadership and management systems and behaviours to support the change

Therefore, perhaps the secret solution to making Lean improvements work lies in having a defined methodology to enable people to be able to understand the Lean Journey (answering the ‘Where do I start?’ question) and a plan of attack to create the right organisational environment to enable the improvements to take hold (answering the ‘Why is it so hard?’ question)?

Well, the answer to the questions above is ‘possibly’ because it all relies on having the expertise to answer the questions that arise – such as ‘What is the right methodology for my business?’, ‘What is the best management structure for my business to support the improvement?’ and ‘How do I overcome organisational inertia?’

Sadly, most people who look to implement Lean (or Six Sigma for that matter) come from an engineering or ‘tools’ background, meaning they fully understand the logic of the improvement tools but often do not have the expertise to address the cultural change and organisational development aspect or impact of what they are proposing. Alternatively, the facilitators come from HR/People/Change Management backgrounds and provide expert facilitation for the teams but little in the way of actual direction. Either approach is normally doomed to failure, either dramatic or gradual.

Therefore, the real secret to success is to combine a strong methodology with supporting activities designed to align the organisation behind the change and back it up with an approach based on a strong understanding of the tools of improvement and the ability to inspire and coordinate individuals and teams.

This short 'think piece' has been prepared by Mark Eaton and Simon Phillips and the authors welcome comments and questions which can be emailed to markeaton@amnis-uk.com

Article source: Expert Articles

Most Recent Articles in Change Management category

  • Ideas to Get Your Started Online $ Marketing Business - By: Thingom Kenedy
    Is the same old routine that you have everyday getting you down? Fighting the traffic to go and sit in an office for 8 hours or more and then joining the rush hour home again. Collecting the kids from school, watching their sports practice or helping with homework, this leaves you no time for yourself at all.
  • Manifesting The Law of Attraction: An Unbiased Evaluation - By: Brian Garvin
    Find out the scoop with relation to Law of Attraction and evaluate if it is proper for you at this time. Please read our original evaluation of Law of Attraction.
  • Small Business Kit For Dummies - By: Ajaay Kumar
    The Small Business Kit for Dummies has eliminated the need for business coaching for many companies because the book explains in enough detail a range of aspects from beginning to continuing a successful business. This book is invaluable to both a new entrepreneur as well as those with plenty of experience.
  • Identifying the Right Venture Capital Firm Partner - By: Rahul Rana
    Venture capital firms are comprised of individual partners. These partners make investment decisions and typically take a seat on each portfolio company's Board. Partners tend to invest in what they know, so finding a partner that has past work experience in your industry is very helpful. This relevant experience allows them to more fully understand your venture's value proposition and gives them confidence that they can add value, thus encouraging them to invest.
  • Business Plan - By: Gaurav Walia
    A is a short brief that explains how a business owner, director or entrepreneur plans to orchestrate an enterprising effort that carries out the actions that are necessary in order for the effort to succeed. Basically, a business plan is the written description of a business's business model. Those involved in the planning process and management are the most likely to use a business plan. Business plans are also used when approaching potential lenders or investors that have an interest in a particular business venture.
  • Data Center Automation - What Your Organization Needs - By: Sam A. Brown
    When it comes to researching resources, there are several aspects worth considering, to ensure that business and operational needs are met. From the basics of implementing a software solution to automate tasks such as provisioning, patching and software distribution, to a full blown multi-tier architecture, data center automation is key.
  • The Power of the Chamber of Commerce - By: Andy Keeler
    Advice on how your Chamber of Commerce can work for you
  • Conference Sessions Focus on Organizational Change - By: Mark Harbeke
    Recently, I summarized the tips and strategies provided in two of the morning sessions at our recent 2006 Best Bosses Conference, held September 27, 2006 in Chicago. Below, I continue in this series of articles dedicated to the knowledge provided by the workplace leaders and experts at the Conference workshops. In recounting the two remaining morning sessions, “Evolution of a Best Boss: Changing to Grow Your Organization” and “Small Steps to Big Culture Change,” the common theme is organizational change.
  • Medical Billing Outsourcing - By: Damian Sofsian
    The medical treatment business has changed significantly in the past few years. It presents many administrative difficulties during the preparation of insurance policy procedures and dealing with complicated claim forms. To avoid these complexities, doctors look out for outside help, and hire representatives to advise them, attend insurance company seminars, and provide them with regular financial reports.
  • Leadership v Management - By: Kevin Hinton
    Change is one of the only certainties in life – it is constant.How we adapt to change will be one of the most determining factor in evaluating our successes or our failures.• where we end up.