Creditors' Committees under Bankruptcy Reform: More Representative?

By: Warren Graham
Submitted: 2007-01-17 16:16:50
Print this article | Tell a friend | For publisher | Social Bookmarking
Rating:
 

The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (BAPCPA), attempted to redress what was perceived to be a failing under prior law. In Chapter 11 Cases (especially larger cases), smaller “trade” creditors and smaller interests were often frozen out of the process and of qualification for Committee membership, by the mere presence of huge bondholder representatives, pension funds, and the like. The intention, under earlier law, was to create a Committee, generally of seven members, consisting of the largest unsecured creditors, with claims generally representative of the types of debt extant in the case. This, of course, proved easier in theory than in practice, as large cases tended to be replete with public debt, managed by institutional holders. The result, often, was that smaller trade creditors, or “mom and pop” businesses were simply not given a seat at the table, and were effectively not afforded the advantages of participation in the reorganization negotiation process.

Under prior law, a conflict developed in the Courts as to whether the bankruptcy court had the power to direct the U.S. Trustee to increase Committee size so as to redress this imbalance of power. It is clear now under BAPCPA that it does, if the creditor seeking membership can satisfy a two-part test: The first part requires that the creditor be a “small business concern,” as that term is defined under the Small Business Act. The definition of that test is beyond the scope of this article, and counsel should be consulted for additional detail. The second requirement, is that the creditor hold a claim or claims which, in the aggregate, “in comparison to the annual gross revenue of that creditor, is disproportionately large.” The term “disproportionately large” is not defined, and will be left to judicial development. The term has been used in certain other bankruptcy contexts, but such use is, in the judgment of this author, of dubious applicability.

It seems obvious, for example, that if 50% of the annual revenues of a “Small Business Concern” is tied up in a bankruptcy case, the provision would apply, but as one goes further down the scale, the cases are likely to reach different results. In any case, in those courts in which the Courts had the power to direct changes in Committee size and composition to provide for adequate representation of types of debt, that discretion does not appear to have been taken away.

In summary, the question of whether “Mom and Pop” have been given a “seat at the table” in large reorganization cases has yet to be tested by the application by the Courts of the new BAPCPA provisions, and only time will tell whether Committees will become “more representative” of types of debt in those situations. Any creditor representative who finds himself or herself in a situation calling for legal analyis in this area is, or course, urged to consult competent counsel.

Warren R. Graham

Copyright 2006

Warren R. Graham is a New York attorney with the Firm of Cohen Tauber Spievack & Wagner LLP. He is a frequent writer on a variety of topics, including legal matters, political and religious affairs. His opinions are his own and do not necessarily reflect the views of his firm or its members. Additional information on him may be found at either http://www.ctswlaw.com/templates/page3_attorney.asp?docid=667 or http://warrenrgrahamlegal.blogspot.com

Article source: Expert Articles

Most Recent Articles in Bankruptcy category

  • How to Avoid Bankruptcy - By: Justin Narin
    Bankruptcy offers some people a clean slate, it is by no means an easy solution. Bankruptcy will destroy your credit and may possibly force you to sell your assets. If you want to preserve your credit, you will be much better off if you do whatever you can to avoid bankruptcy.
  • Make Filing for Bankruptcy a Last Resort - By: Lee Bell
    There are 2 main types of bankruptcy. If you can't avoid bankruptcy, determine between Chapter 7 and Chapter 13.
  • Life after bankruptcy is not so difficult - By: Jason Holmes
    "Avoid bankruptcy" is the most common phrase; we come across in our everyday life. There are several disadvantages of bankruptcy. But if you are bankrupt, it is not very difficult to swim out of the situation.
  • Achieving Financial Security in an Unreliable Economy - By: Mohan Mittal
    Financial Security is a false concept that developed in American society based on the idea that security comes from the perceived reliability of a regular or planned paycheck. Many people, believing in the commitment of their corporations to their well-being, have found themselves downsized, layed-off, outsourced, transferred, or, in some cases, even fired. The immediate reality becomes harshly apparent and sadly disappointing.
  • Bankruptcy - Is it the Last Option Only? - By: Michael Killian
    Bankruptcy is available when all other debt payment measures have failed and the unpaid debt is simply beyond the means of the consumer to repay. It is essential, then, to understand debt options prior to bankruptcy and to determine which debt repayment method is the least detrimental. Additionally it is the law of the land that you know your debt repayment options prior to bankruptcy.
  • It’s Official; We Are Now A Bankrupt Society? - By: Stephen Morgan
    The Government’s Insolvency Service claimed that 27,644 people were either made bankrupt or entered into an Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA) as a way to control or manage their debts in an ordered fashion.It was too early obviously to know how big a percentage of those who entered into an IVA had it failed by their manager or supervisor but it has been claimed previously that in some cases up to 50/60 percent of those entering an IVA fail to complete it in an orderly manner and therefore find themselves being made forcibly bankrupt at a later date.The other key statistic was that insolvencies were apparently 55% higher than during the comparable period this time last year and the smart money (to spoil the metaphor) is on the figure topping the 100,000 mark for the year.
  • Considerations Before Filing Bankruptcy - By: Jon Arnold
    Financial difficulties can occur in anyone’s life. When you think financial difficulties are more than you can handle, don’t let bankruptcy become your first thought. Bankruptcy should be considered as a last resort, not just the first thing that pops into your head when the going gets tough.
  • People on Benefits No Longer Eligible for an IVA - By: Diana Middleton
    The BBC has reported that people on UK state benefits will no longer be given an option of taking out an IVA to help pay off their debts.In an IVA or Individual Voluntary Arrangement people negotiate a repayment plan with their creditors with an Insolvency Practitioner acting on their behalf. Up to 80% of their debt is written off and interest on debt is frozen.
  • How Do Bankruptcy Loans' Requirements Work? - By: Kate Ross
    Bankruptcy loan’s qualification is not an easy task. You need to overcome serious lender’s wariness about your ability and disposition for repaying the loan you are requesting. At this stage, you need to make no mistakes, your behavior has to be stainless and you need to show the lender that the past problems that led you to bankruptcy exist no more.
  • Bankruptcy Can Be Used As An Opportunity To Start Over And Reset Your Financial Goals - By: Jon Hansen
    Bankruptcy is the last resort that neither the borrower nor the creditor wishes to meet. The impact of this to both sides is negative and long-lasting. Once you are bankrupt, it will remain on your credit report for many years, making it difficult to get any loan, insurance, or a job.