Whether a National Minimum Wage Reduces Relative Poverty

By: Richard Pettinger
Submitted: 2007-01-17 16:23:56
Print this article | Tell a friend | For publisher | Social Bookmarking
Rating:
 

Relative poverty reflects the fact that some sections of society have an income far lower (e.g. 50% less) than the average salary. In the UK the National Minimum wage is a legal requirement. Firms must pay workers an hourly wage of at least ?5.05 for those over 21. The development rate for those 18-21 is ?4.35

Since the introduction of the NMW many low paid workers have seen an increase in the hourly wage as firms are obliged to pay workers the statutory minimum wage. To some extent this has helped reduce relative poverty as the lowest paid workers have seen a significant increase in their weekly income. This is more prevalent in the North where wages tended to be lower, fewer jobs in the south have been affected by the NMW.

However it is worth noting that the poorest sections of society tend to be those on benefits such as JSA (60% of the poorest tend to be unemployed) and incapacity benefits, therefore these groups will not benefit from a NMW. Also many on the NMW may be second income earners e.g. the wife of a main breadwinner. Therefore these households may be quite well off and would not classify as being relatively poor anyway. Therefore this is a limitation of the NMW in reducing poverty.

Another concern about the NMW is that if it was increase it may cause unemployment. According to classical theory an increase in the NMW will lead to real wage unemployment.

The extent of unemployment would depend upon the elasticity of demand for labour, if it was inelastic unemployment would only increase a little. However If there was an increase in unemployment this would have the effect of increasing relative poverty rather than reducing it.. This problem may be most likely to occur in industries with low profit margins and regions where equilibrium wages tend to be low.

However evidence suggests that UK labour markets are not perfectly competitive but employers may have significant Monopsony power. This is especially true part time temporary service sector jobs where workers have little union representation and few rights. If workers face Monopsonist a higher Minimum wage may not cause unemployment, in some circumstances it may decrease

Empirical evidence suggest that increasing the NMW does not cause unemployment to increase suggesting this model is more accurate than the classical view. However it will clearly depend upon how much the NMW is increased. It is also likely that some labour markets will be more competitive than others therefore the effect may differ for different industries.

Other positive benefits of the NMW include the fact it may increase the incentive for the unemployed to get a job rather than stay on benefits, however the JSA is quite low and the gap between benefits and work is quite high already.

In conclusion an increase in the NMW can help the low paid increase their income, thereby reducing relative poverty to some extent. A serious concern about an increase is that in some labour markets it may cause real wage unemployment therefore increasing poverty. However evidence suggests that the increase would have to be very significant for this to occur because many labour markets tend to be uncompetitive. There could also be a case for increasing the NMW more in the south where wages tend to be higher, thereby reducing relative poverty in the south.

In conclusion raising the minimum wage can cause a decrease in relative poverty for those in work but its extent is limited as much poverty stems from those living on welfare benefits. In the US the benefits of raising the minimum wage are likely to be higher because of the large numbers of workers working close to the statutory minimum wage.

R. Pettinger is an economics teacher in Oxford where he studied PPE at LMH, Oxford University. He writes on Economics, Spirituality and has written many biographies at http://www.biographyonline.net/ He is a member of the Sri Chinmoy Centre

Article source: Expert Articles

Most Recent Articles in Economics category

  • Developments Prior to the Currency Debates - By: Rupert Mackenzie
    During the 18th century England was nominally on a bimetallic standard (consisting of silver and gold), however, the mint price of silver was intentionally undervalued to keep it out of circulation and thus a de facto gold standard functioned: banknotes issued both by the Bank of England and country banks were convertible into gold upon request.
  • Investors Moving Money to European Banks Fearing U.S. Economy and Major Bank Failures - By: Brett Schoneman
    "Many investors are placing part of their hard-earned money out of harms way into foreign banks that do not have exposure to the U.S. sub-prime mortgage crises," says Kevin Wessell, CEO of Offshore Company. Mr. Wessell is also the author of "Build Your Financial Castle" and a nationally renowned asset protection seminar speaker.
  • The success of Africa's exports - By: Paul McIndoe
    While Africa faces tremendous challenges on the road to integration into the world trading system, many African export sectors have actually outperformed world market growth.
  • The 10 Movers and Shakers in Turkey's Banking Sector - By: James Kara Murat
    In Turkey there are many sectors active and dynamic and the banking sector is one of them. The dynamism of the banking sector is a result of the lifting of certain restrictions
  • The Biggest Banking Mergers & Acquisitions in Turkey - By: James Kara Murat
    Turkey is making some economic reforms in order to become part of the European Union. As a result, the Turkish banking industry has seen many changes.
  • Barcelona economy - By: Kirsty Connell
    Barcelona has a highly diversified economic structure. Find out the facts which lead to the growth of Barcelona economy.
  • Indian Retailers Accelerate Evolving Pace - By: Gaurav Doshi
    Retail industry in India is gradually edging its way towards becoming the next boom industry with contributing more than 10% to Country’s GDP and around 8% employment. Several Indian and global players are developing strategies to enter such a fast paced and growing market. Also the whole retail industry is taking new shape, the traditional market giving way for the more organized market in the form of departmental stores, hypermarkets, supermarkets and specialty stores.
  • The Real State of the Economy - Good or Bad? - By: Stephen Morgan
    There is something about the US Economy at the moment that I for one don’t get. Now it may be that being a brit, I am a little slow on the uptake; this has been known to happen every now and then but at the moment I cannot fathom several things out.Firstly, the UK economy, despite the Chancellors proud claims, is not in exactly the best of shapes but in the US, the Government is technically, if not practically bankrupt.
  • India Emerging As A Global Healthcare Destination - By: Christine Macguire
    Health is vital for ethical, artistic, material and spiritual development of man. It is very certain that of all the gains, the gains of health are the highest and the best. Traveling abroad for treatment has been an age-old practice.
  • India-Srilanka Free Trade Agreement(FTA): The Success and Road Ahead - By: Dr Suvrokamal Dutta
    The Free Trade Agreement between India and Srilanka came into full existence from 1st March 2000.This FTA basically deals with the modalities of the Duty Free Import of the Goods manufactured in Srilanka. Which exempt specified goods imported under Indo-Srilanka Free Trade Agreement from the Import Duty up to 100%.